PreviousNext

Oculus Book Review: When Ivory Towers Were Black by Sharon E. Sutton

Book Reviews by • 03/09

Dr. Sharon Egrette Sutton’s recent book, When Ivory Towers Were Black, is a three-pronged exploration of the cultural, educational, and personal events surrounding the 1968 student insurgency on the Columbia University campus. Sutton describes her experience as a minority student after the insurrection and tells the tale of Columbia before and after. During her Oculus Book Talk lecture on 02.13.17 at the Center of Architecture, Sutton explained that, unlike today, when diversity aspiration ally seen as a way to balance and improve communities, in 1968, the fight against racism and efforts towards creating diverse academic communities were issues of national security. The summer of 1968 numbered 163 racial confrontations in the inner cities of the US. The Ivy League was about to become ground zero for change.

Sutton’s chapter on the student insurgency covers how thirty or so architecture students occupied the architecture school’s Avery Hall, protesting the racist and expansionist policies of the university. The breaking up of the occupation was a shocking, violent event. The Avery insurgents, who had been conceptualizing a new approach to architectural education during the sit-in, became fully radicalized. The Columbia University insurgency uncoupled the educational value system that the hallowed Columbia halls had maintained and, as a result, the architecture curriculum exploded. When outdoor “teach-ins” organically grew out of the Strike Coordinating Committee boycott of classes held inside Columbia buildings, a new way to learn became possible. Sutton carefully describes the “platform” curriculum for the architecture school, the one she walked into in 1970.

Sutton, along with her 56 minority peers, experienced a climate of academic freedom and experimentation during her time studying architecture. Students looked to the adjacent Harlem community for inspiration and moral guidance. Columbia’s community-based Architects Renewal Committee of Harlem (ARCH) is a fascinating precursor to the design/build Rural Studio program at Auburn University; Columbia University was at the forefront of social justice design challenges and advances.

Sadly, after an accreditation body found fault with the university’s structural problems in general, this curriculum revolution ended, as did the architecture school’s mandate to recruit minority students. Sutton records a finite moment of moral clarity and invention in architectural education.

Sutton digs deeply into a discussion of the academic administrative machinations, but it takes a particular mind to follow all the slights and injustices that an academic environment can bring forth. This section is not as strong as her narrative of the insurgency and its major players. James Stewart Polshek comes off as a young man trying to maintain authority rather than an insightful leader during his time as Dean of GSAPP, and other administrators are hard to distinguish in the narrative. The aftermath of the curriculum revolution coincides with Nixon’s election, and a law and order mandate shifts the tone of academia – chilling in light of our current political climate.

Sutton’s prose is luscious and lively; the first paragraph of the introduction is a captivating prophecy of an institution breaking down and its will to rebuild for the good. Her multitude of voices, however, sometimes confuse her narrative. At times, her almost Shakespearian intimacy with the audience is at odds with her polished, academically rigorous tone that pervades the interviews and much of the text.

But ultimately, Sutton sets out a clear road map of the historical framework that these 50 or so students of color found themselves in, a road map where diversity and community inclusion is how one practices architecture and is a citizen of the world.

Event: Oculus Book Talk: When Ivory Towers Were Black: A Story about Race in America’s Cities and Universities
Location: Center for Architecture, 02.13.17
Speakers: Dr. Sharon Egretta Sutton, FAIA, Professor Emerita of Architecture and Design, University of Washington; Carol Loewenson, FAIA, LEED AP, Partner, Mitchell | Giurgola Architects
Organized by: AIANY Oculus Committee

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

World Trade Center Transportation Hub Oculus Interior, New York, NY. Credit: Peter Aaron.
Featured Member: Thomas Grassi Elevated to AIA College of Fellows AIA News You Can Use
Credit: Martin Falbisoner/Wikimedia.
Policy Pulse: 300 Architects, Advocates and Leaders Attend AIA Grassroots Conference Policy Pulse
Hugh Hardy at the New York Academy of Sciences. Credit: Kristen Richards, Hon. AIA, Hon. ASLA.
Remembering New York Architect Hugh Hardy, FAIA (1931-2017) In Memoriam
Allie Mae Public Library, View of Story Hour Corner, New Orleans, LA. Photo: Courtesy of MDA Designgroup.
Featured Member: Elisabeth Martin Elevated to AIA College of Fellows AIA News You Can Use
Alex O'Briant takes the mic. Credit: Center for Architecture.
Busting Myths: How Can Social Research Impact Design? At the Center for Architecture
The TRA Studio-designed restoration of the façade of the New York Academy of Art (NYAA). Credit: TRA Studio.
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
Yolande Daniels' Josai I-House Togane Global Village by studioSUMO is featured in "SAY IT LOUD: Distinguished Black Designers of NYCOBA | NOMA." Credit: Kawasumi Kobayashi Kenji Photo Co. Ltd.
On View On View
300,000 aluminum cans, recycled and cast into cracked clay, form Cast & Place: City of Dreams Pavilion, slated for NYC's Governors Island this summer. This project will only be funded if it reaches its goal by 03.27.17!
New Deadlines New Deadlines
IMG_0810-2
Classifieds Classifieds
Categories: Best in Show; Architecture Honor Award. Architect: Diller Scofidio + Renfro. Executive Architect: Gensler. Landscape Architect: SCAPE. Project: The Roy and Diana Vagelos Education Center, Columbia University. Location: New York, NY. Photo: Iwan Baan.
AIA New York Names 2017 Design Awards Winners AIA News You Can Use
Zach Inglis via Unsplash
Driverless Future Challenge Policy Pulse
From left: Farzana Gandhi; T. Alexander Aleinkoff; Sean Anderson; Eliza Montgomery; Alfredo Brillembourg. Credit: Center for Architecture.
Designing for the Refugee Crisis Reveals Both Hard Truths and Hope At the Center for Architecture
When Ivory Towers Were Black: A Story about Race in America’s Cities and Universities by Sharon Egretta Sutton, FAIA.
Oculus Book Review: When Ivory Towers Were Black by Sharon E. Sutton Book Reviews
John Cetra, FAIA, co-founder, CetraRuddy Architecture. Credit: Evan Sung.
Featured Member: John Cetra Elevated to AIA College of Fellows AIA News You Can Use
Adrian and Jack work on their birdhouse designs.
Students Design Animal Architecture at Studio@theCenter Learning by Design
300,000 aluminum cans, recycled and cast into cracked clay, form Cast & Place: City of Dreams Pavilion, slated for NYC's Governors Island this summer. This project will only be funded if it reaches its goal by 03.27.17!
In the News In The News
Belfer Research Building, Weill Cornell Medicine, New York, NY. Photo: Jeff Goldberg/Esto.
Featured Member: William Cunningham Elevated to AIA College of Fellows AIA News You Can Use
Names in the News Names in the News
05.19.17: Call for Entries: Blank Space/City of New York/New Lab/AIANY/ Fast Company’s The Driverless Future Challenge
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“Follies, Function & Form: Imagining Olana’s Summer House,” through 04.22.17
On View On View
Offices Available for Rent
Classifieds Classifieds
Ann Marie Baranowski, FAIA. Credit: Paulette Pascarella.
Featured Member: Ann Marie Baranowski Elevated to AIA College of Fellows AIA News You Can Use
Square 650 pixels_final
Spotlight on the 2017 AIANY Design Awards Jury AIA News You Can Use
The Forest House Apartments in the Bronx, recipient of LIHTC
Housing Policy: A Closer Look Policy Pulse
1 - Lighting Up at PS1 This Summer
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
05.19.17: Call for Entries: Blank Space/City of New York/New Lab/AIANY/ Fast Company’s The Driverless Future Challenge
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“Architecture of Independence – African Modernism,” through 05.27.17
On View On View
Classifieds Classifieds
Patrick J. Burke, FAIA, Assistant VP, Capital Management, Columbia University Medical Center. Credit: Edmund M. Kramer Photographers, Inc.
Featured Member: Patrick J. Burke III Elevated to AIA College of Fellows AIA News You Can Use
AIANY Releases Guiding Statements From the Executive Director
Sharswood Blumberg Redevelopment in Philadelphia
Announcing the Winner of the 2016 Stewardson Keefe LeBrun Travel Grant Center News
Architects Advocate published an open letter to President Trump regarding actions addressing climate change.
Architects Advocate Open Letter to President Trump Policy Pulse
New York Coalition of Black Architects (NYCOBA) Members, 1979. Credit: NYCOBA.
‘SAY IT LOUD’ Includes Timeline of Black Architects in New York At the Center for Architecture
Manual of Section by Paul Lewis, AIA; Marc Tsurumaki, AIA; and David J. Lewis, AIA.
Oculus Book Review: Manual of Section by Paul Lewis, Marc Tsurumaki, and David J. Lewis Book Reviews
1 - New in NoHo
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“Architecture of Independence – African Modernism,” opening 02.16.17
On View On View
Desks for rent in TriBeCa
Classifieds Classifieds
Representatives from at least 10 different architectural and urbanist groups joined the Women's March on Washington.
Architects Build Hope at Women’s March Reports from the Field
The New York Cypher of the nationwide Design as Protest event focused on new ways to use design in support of at-risk communities.
Policy Pulse: Design As Protest in NYC Policy Pulse
Nominate AIA Architects for Fellowship! AIA News You Can Use
Proud parents listen as PS Q300 second graders talk about the neighborhood model they made during a culminating presentation.
First Semester Wrap-Up Learning by Design
Over 300 attendees gathered at the Center for Architecture. Photography by Center for Architecture.
NYCHA Debuts Design Guidelines for Improving Public Housing At the Center for Architecture
1 - Two Performance Venues in One Space
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
02.03.17: Call for Entries: AIANY 2017 Design Awards
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“SAY IT LOUD: Distinguished Black Designers of NYCOBA | NOMA,” through 04.01.17
On View On View