PreviousNext

The New Yorker Who Carried Taliesin Back Home

At the Center for Architecture by • 02/05

Among many stories told at this lively celebration of the later work of Edgar Tafel, FAIA – a natural and engaging raconteur, he was also the subject of quite a few tales over the years – his frequent collaborator Robert Silman related one about the decision to study under Frank Lloyd Wright at Taliesin. Young Tafel had been unimpressed with what he heard as a student in NYU’s architecture program (now defunct) during the 1930s: “These professors don’t know what they’re talking about,” he groused to relatives. Then his aunt saw a newspaper article on the Taliesin Fellowship. What it didn’t say, Silman added, was that “they paid Wright to work for him.” The financial obstacle was considerable, but Wright’s reply to Tafel’s application was something anyone young, talented, ambitious, and shallow-pocketed would want to hear: “Pay what you can, but come.” That exchange, we all now know, changed his life. It also put him, for better or worse, in the orbit of the mentor he would always call “Mr. Wright.” After striking out on his own in 1941 (not without friction, but never with an irreparable break), Tafel contributed distinguished buildings to New York City and other locations, particularly in the religious, academic, residential, and community-service sectors. He worked and lived, Silman noted, with his Wright books constantly open. For the notoriously Manhattan-phobic master, meetings with his old apprentice “Mr. Tafel” may have been the sole unmixed blessing during his stays at the Plaza Hotel. Tafel also developed a second career writing and lecturing about his association with Wright after closing down his solo practice in 1986.

“A part of him never left Taliesin,” Silman commented, raising the unanswerable question of whether the association held him back in certain respects. Tafel’s strong sense of social mission and his delight in bringing quirky, broadly allusive touches to modern buildings on large and small scales add up to a distinctive approach that cannot be reduced to its undeniable chief influence; neither can he be seen apart from it. Tafel, as Caroline Rob Zaleski discussed in thorough detail, brought Wright’s visual language to SUNY Geneseo, where he was involved for a decade in planning that Nelson Rockefeller-era upstate campus (alongside Rolf Myller, Richard Snibbe, and Einar Lindholm), and designing several major buildings. He served as associate-in-charge on the three-winged Fine Arts Building, whose double-height atrium hints at Wright’s Larkin Building (1906-1950) in nearby Buffalo. “I was bothered by an enormous problem of identity,” Zaleski quoted Tafel saying, reluctant either to be wholly overshadowed or to dissociate himself. Wright explicitly spoke of himself as a spiritual second father to Tafel (as to other Fellows), with stronger obligations than mere “blood” parents could claim. With such burdens and benefits intertwined, their combined weight is scarcely imaginable.

Yet the distinctive elements in Tafel’s work, particularly in churches and synagogues, contended Kimbro Frutiger, call for reappraisal and renewed appreciation. Tafel’s willingness to juxtapose historical and local reference points in what Frutiger calls a “rebus of forms” arguably anticipated Postmodernism. One of his important Episcopal churches, St. John’s in the Village (West 11th Street at Waverly Place), is commonly considered a Modernist take on the Greek Revival, but instead strikes Frutiger as “Brutalist Romanesque Orthodox.” In the small-scaled Madison Avenue Methodist Church near Harlem’s Taft Houses, Tafel experimented with fake-mansard roofing, to intriguing effect, long before that form acquired parking-lot fast-food connotations; “awkward is sometimes quite interesting,” Frutiger commented. His likely masterpiece is Church House at First Presbyterian (Fifth Avenue at 12th Street), a home for a progressive religious community and an “anti-Guggenheim… straightforward, but not normative,” where precast panels of quatrefoil ornamentation complicate a façade that visually rhymes with the brickwork and terra cotta of Chicago’s Chapin and Gore Building by Hugh M. G. Garden and Richard Schmidt. Far from being a two-dimensional epigone of Wright, Tafel dared to abandon the organic and weave witty, personal idiosyncrasies with public service.

Tafel’s primary-source archive is now in the hands of Columbia’s Avery Library, which also holds the massive Wright archive in a partnership with the Museum of Modern Art. Janet Parks and Tania Franco described the materials now available for scholars and the public, including a wealth of correspondence and other documents at Avery, with Wright’s models and other three-dimensional materials at MoMA. The labors of untangling and organizing Tafel’s writings and records were formidable, as reflected in Franco’s meta-archiving blog. What emerges is a portrait of an energetic, engaged, complex urban citizen, the product of a progressive upbringing in his youth and a prolific contributor to the architectural literature in his maturity. With Avery serving as a kind of posthumous virtual Taliesin, master and apprentice are now back together. On some level, one would like to imagine that Mr. Wright has made his peace with New York at last.

Bill Millard is a freelance writer and editor whose work has appeared in Oculus, IconThe Architect’s Newspaper, and other publications.

Event: Practice Post-50: Edgar Tafel in New York
Location: Center for Architecture, 01.23. 14
Speakers: Janet Parks, Curator of Drawings and Archives, Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library, Columbia University; Tania Franco, Project Archivist, Edgar Tafel Archive; Kimbro Frutiger, Architect, Author, Edgar Tafel’s Religious Work: Design, Traditions, Ethics; Caroline Rob Zaleski, Author, Edgar Tafel and SUNY Geneseo: Lessons from Frank Lloyd Wright; Robert Silman, President Emeritus, Robert Silman Associates (moderator); Carol Ann Fabian, Director, Avery Library (introduction); Rick Bell, FAIA, AIANY Executive Director
Organizers: Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library, Columbia University and AIANY Historic Buildings Committee

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

AIANY 2015 President Tomas Rossant, AIA, and AIANY 2014 President Lance Jay Brown, FAIA (center).
Editor’s Note Editor's Note
Paul Katz, FAIA
In Memoriam: Paul Katz In Memoriam
On 11.20.14, the NYC Department of City Planning organized a panel discussion on retrofitting urban buildings for flood risk.
Equitable Efficiency Policy Pulse
Alan Mallach, senior fellow of the National Housing Institute, senior fellow at the Center for Community Progress, and senior fellow at the Brookings Institution.
Samuel Ratensky Memorial Lecture Transcript At the Center for Architecture
13 area architecture school deans discussed leadership at the 2014 Deans' Roundtable.
2014 Deans’ Roundtable At the Center for Architecture
David Fishman, co-author of Paradise Planned, presented on the evolution of suburbs at the November 2014 Oculus Book Talk.
Oculus Book Review: Paradise Planned: The Garden Suburb and the Modern City, by Robert A.M. Stern, David Fishman, and Jacob Tilove At the Center for Architecture
Rick Bell, FAIA, AIANY; Elin Bergithe Rognlie, Consulate General of Norway; Ingrid Moe, Consulate General of Norway; Kati Laakso, Consulate General of Finland in New York; Emmi Keskisarja, Architect; Miia-Liina Tommila, Architect; Caitlin Mehner, Performer; and David Gelles, Performer
Infinite Diversities At the Center for Architecture
Stanis Smith, FRAIC, AIA, LEED AP, Executive Vice President for Buildings, Sector Leader, Airports, Stantec
Zip-a-ding Through the Airport: Place-Oriented Playlands At the Center for Architecture
Rick Bell, FAIA, AIANY; Gabriel Smith, AIA, Thomas Phifer and Partners; Lee H. Skolnick, FAIA, Lee H. Skolnick Architecture + Design Partnership; Scott Briggs, AIA, AIANY Cultural Facilities Committee; Audrey Matlock, FAIA, Audrey Matlock Architect; and Katie Gerfen, Architect magazine
American Architects Working in Post-Soviet Culture Sectors At the Center for Architecture
Hana Kassem, AIA, LEED AP, Kohn Pedersen Fox Associates; Lance Jay Brown, FAIA, AIANY; Alejandro Zaera-Polo, AZPML; Florian Idenburg, Intl. Assoc. AIA, SO-IL; Dan Gallagher, NADAAA; Nader Tehrani, NADAAA; and Hashim Sarkis, MIT School of Architecture and Planning
Melting Pot At the Center for Architecture
The Center for Architecture Foundation (CFAF) hosted the annual Architecture and Design College Fair on 11.21.14
CFAF Hosts Architecture and Design College Fair At the Center for Architecture Foundation
1 - Fantasy Island
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
02.06.15: Call for Entries: AIANY Design Awards 2015
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“Saul Steinberg Drawings | Architecture Public Space” through 01.03.15
On View: At the Center for Architecture + About Town About Town
11.13.14: At the “Geometry and Structure in Architecture” event, organized by the Center for Architecture and the Museum of the City of New York, speakers discussed the interactions between mathematics and geometry in architecture. (l-r) SawTeen See, Managing Partner, and Leslie E. Robertson, Founder, Leslie E. Robertson Associates; William F. Baker, Structural Engineering Partner, Skidmore, Owings & Merrill; Erleen Hatfield, AIA, LEED AP, PE, Principal, Buro Happold; and Susan Henshaw Jones, Ronay Menschel Director, Museum of the City of New York.
Sighted Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
11.15.14: "Arch Schools 2014" and Deans' Roundtable
Editor’s Note Editor's Note
AIA Europe founder Alan Schwartzman, FAIA, shown here with AIA National Vice President Susan Chin, FAIA, received a prolonged standing ovation while receiving two AIA Europe awards.
Musings on AIA in Europe Rhetorically Speaking
Roland Lewis, Roland Lewis, President & CEO, Metropolitan Waterfront Alliance, introduces the South Street Seaport Public Forum on 10.10.14.
Planning the ‘Port: A Public Conversation on Development at the South Street Seaport Policy Pulse
Alexander Garvin, president and CEO of Alex Garvin & Associates and professor at Yale School of Architecture presented on the creation of a light rail line to connect Queens to Brooklyn.
Millenials Bring Back the Trolley? At the Center for Architecture
William Menking, Architect’s Newspaper; Sara Reisman, Percent for Art Program, NYC Department of Cultural Affairs; Aleksey Lukyanov-Cherny, Situ Studio; Susan Chin, FAIA, Design Trust for Public Space; James Carpenter, James Carpenter Design Associates; Sandra Bloodworth, Arts and Urban Design, MTA; and Andrew Whalley, Grimshaw.
Publicly Available At the Center for Architecture
Debra Pickrel, AIANY Marketing & Communications Committee; Gonzalo V. Cruz, ASLA, Landscape Architecture Studio NYC, AECOM; Gretchen Bank, AIANY Marketing & Communications Committee; AIANY 2014 President Lance Jay Brown, FAIA; William Menking, The Architect's Newspaper; Adam Yarinsky, FAIA, Architecture Research Office; and Susannah Drake, FASLA, AIA, dlandstudio architecture + landscape architecture
Landing Space At the Center for Architecture
Casablanca Chandigarh: A Report on Modernization, published by the Canadian Centre for Architecture and Park Books.
Oculus Quick Take: Casablanca Chandigarh: A Report on Modernization Podcast
A Learning By Design:NY residency with a 6th grade class at PS 102 in Queens integrated a social studies unit on the Middle Ages and math skills of scale measurement into their art class by designing and building scale models of typical medieval townhouses.
Center for Architecture Foundation Awarded $50,000 Grant from Deutsche Bank Americas Foundation At the Center for Architecture Foundation
1 - Take the A (or the 2, 3, 4, 5, C, J, Z, and and R lines) to the Fulton Center
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
02.06.15: Call for Entries: AIANY Design Awards
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“Saul Steinberg Drawings | Architecture Public Space” through 01.03.15
On View: At the Center for Architecture At the Center for Architecture
10.27.14: Organizers and speakers at the annual J. Max Bond Jr. Memorial Lecture, “Conversations | Equity Agendas,” discussed how the agendas of affordability, housing, and community fit into the de Blasio administration: (l-r) Karen Kubey, Institute for Public Architecture (IPA); Miriam Peterson and Nathan Rich, Peterson Rich Office; Sagi Golan,  NYC Department of Planning; Mark Gardner, AIA, AIANY Diversity & Inclusion Committee; Nadine Maleh, Inspiring Places for Community Solutions; Quilian Riano, DSGNAGNC and  NYDesigns; Marc Norman, 2014-15 Loeb Fellow, Harvard GSD; Kaja Kühl, Columbia University GSAPP 5 Borough Studio; Mindy Fullilove, AIA, Columbia University; and Venesa Alicea, AIA, AIANY Diversity & Inclusion Committee.
Sighted Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
Archtober 2014
Editor’s Note Editor's Note
“Architecture comes from the Greek word arkitekton, meaning we’re going to be about 120% over budget.” Robert De Niro’s engaging speech mixed humor with a vast understanding of the standards of architecture, quoting the three Vitruvian qualities of “solidity, usefulness, and beauty.”
Heritage Ball 2014: Talkin’ to the Architects Reports from the Field
Friends of LaGuardia President Lawrence Goldberg served as master of ceremonies at the neighborhood association's annual dinner.
Hawkish about LaGuardia Rhetorically Speaking
Speakers at "Issues in Civic Visioning: A Town + Gown Event" at the Center for Architecture.
New York City: Open for Building Policy Pulse
NOMA Design Excellence award winner and AIA New York Chapter member Pascale Sablan, AIA, (center) pictured with (l-r) Venesa Alicea, AIA; Jack Travis, FAIA; 2016 AIA President-elect Russell Davidson, FAIA; and nycobaNOMA Past-president Tonja Adair, AIA.
NOMA: For the LOVE of it Reports from the Field
Eeva-Liisa Pelkonen, Associate Professor, Yale School of Architecture; Jeanne Gang, FAIA, Founder and Principal, Studio Gang Architects; Cara Cragan, Director of Architecture, Helsinki and Abu Dhabi, Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation; Nancy Spector, Deputy Director and Jennifer and David Stockman Chief Curator, Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation; and Joel Sanders, Professor Adjunct, Yale School of Architecture
To the Finland Website: To Get an Icon, Don’t Strive for One At the Center for Architecture
Brad Cloepfil, AIA, founder of Allied Works Architecture, delivered this year's annual Arthur M. Rosenblatt Memorial Lecture organized by the AIANY Cultural Facilities Committee.
Allied in Architecture and Arts At the Center for Architecture
SculptureCenter Executive Director Mary Ceruti and Andrew Berman, FAIA, guided architecture enthusiasts through a tour of the recently-opened SculptureCenter in Long Island City.
Sculpting the Center Reports from the Field
Architect and urbanist Jaime Lerner was joined by former NYC Department of Transportation Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan.
Sustainable Innovation in Urban Planning: Jaime Lerner’s Visionary Success Reports from the Field
One mile of rock, thousands of feet deep, is being excavated out of Manhattan, carted through Queens to Pennsylvania, to make way for MTA’s East Side Access.
Assessing MTA’s East Side Access Reports from the Field
Szenasy, Design Advocate
Oculus Quick Take: Szenasy, Design Advocate Podcast
One group of UASDC students presents their garden design featuring a series of outdoor rooms accommodating different activities along an axis.
High School Students Plant the Seeds for Change in a Local Playground and Garden At the Center for Architecture Foundation
1 - Not Just Another Pretty Façade
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
11.10.14: Call for Entries: 2014 AIANY Committee on the Environment (COTE) Awards
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“New Practices New York 2014” through 01.17.15
On View: At the Center for Architecture At the Center for Architecture
10.15.14: Introduced by AIANY 2014 President Lance Jay Brown, FAIA, Jeffrey Inaba, Assoc. AIA, led Archtober enthusiasts on a Building of the Day tour of Red Bull Studios, a slick 38,000-square-foot music studio/gallery/corporate office.
Sighted Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
NYC Department of Construction (DDC) Commissioner Feniosky Peña-Mora spoke about the search for a new Chief Architect at the Center for Architecture.
Calling all Architects: The NYC Department of Design + Construction Searches for a Chief Architect Editor's Note