PreviousNext

The New Yorker Who Carried Taliesin Back Home

At the Center for Architecture by • 02/05

Among many stories told at this lively celebration of the later work of Edgar Tafel, FAIA – a natural and engaging raconteur, he was also the subject of quite a few tales over the years – his frequent collaborator Robert Silman related one about the decision to study under Frank Lloyd Wright at Taliesin. Young Tafel had been unimpressed with what he heard as a student in NYU’s architecture program (now defunct) during the 1930s: “These professors don’t know what they’re talking about,” he groused to relatives. Then his aunt saw a newspaper article on the Taliesin Fellowship. What it didn’t say, Silman added, was that “they paid Wright to work for him.” The financial obstacle was considerable, but Wright’s reply to Tafel’s application was something anyone young, talented, ambitious, and shallow-pocketed would want to hear: “Pay what you can, but come.” That exchange, we all now know, changed his life. It also put him, for better or worse, in the orbit of the mentor he would always call “Mr. Wright.” After striking out on his own in 1941 (not without friction, but never with an irreparable break), Tafel contributed distinguished buildings to New York City and other locations, particularly in the religious, academic, residential, and community-service sectors. He worked and lived, Silman noted, with his Wright books constantly open. For the notoriously Manhattan-phobic master, meetings with his old apprentice “Mr. Tafel” may have been the sole unmixed blessing during his stays at the Plaza Hotel. Tafel also developed a second career writing and lecturing about his association with Wright after closing down his solo practice in 1986.

“A part of him never left Taliesin,” Silman commented, raising the unanswerable question of whether the association held him back in certain respects. Tafel’s strong sense of social mission and his delight in bringing quirky, broadly allusive touches to modern buildings on large and small scales add up to a distinctive approach that cannot be reduced to its undeniable chief influence; neither can he be seen apart from it. Tafel, as Caroline Rob Zaleski discussed in thorough detail, brought Wright’s visual language to SUNY Geneseo, where he was involved for a decade in planning that Nelson Rockefeller-era upstate campus (alongside Rolf Myller, Richard Snibbe, and Einar Lindholm), and designing several major buildings. He served as associate-in-charge on the three-winged Fine Arts Building, whose double-height atrium hints at Wright’s Larkin Building (1906-1950) in nearby Buffalo. “I was bothered by an enormous problem of identity,” Zaleski quoted Tafel saying, reluctant either to be wholly overshadowed or to dissociate himself. Wright explicitly spoke of himself as a spiritual second father to Tafel (as to other Fellows), with stronger obligations than mere “blood” parents could claim. With such burdens and benefits intertwined, their combined weight is scarcely imaginable.

Yet the distinctive elements in Tafel’s work, particularly in churches and synagogues, contended Kimbro Frutiger, call for reappraisal and renewed appreciation. Tafel’s willingness to juxtapose historical and local reference points in what Frutiger calls a “rebus of forms” arguably anticipated Postmodernism. One of his important Episcopal churches, St. John’s in the Village (West 11th Street at Waverly Place), is commonly considered a Modernist take on the Greek Revival, but instead strikes Frutiger as “Brutalist Romanesque Orthodox.” In the small-scaled Madison Avenue Methodist Church near Harlem’s Taft Houses, Tafel experimented with fake-mansard roofing, to intriguing effect, long before that form acquired parking-lot fast-food connotations; “awkward is sometimes quite interesting,” Frutiger commented. His likely masterpiece is Church House at First Presbyterian (Fifth Avenue at 12th Street), a home for a progressive religious community and an “anti-Guggenheim… straightforward, but not normative,” where precast panels of quatrefoil ornamentation complicate a façade that visually rhymes with the brickwork and terra cotta of Chicago’s Chapin and Gore Building by Hugh M. G. Garden and Richard Schmidt. Far from being a two-dimensional epigone of Wright, Tafel dared to abandon the organic and weave witty, personal idiosyncrasies with public service.

Tafel’s primary-source archive is now in the hands of Columbia’s Avery Library, which also holds the massive Wright archive in a partnership with the Museum of Modern Art. Janet Parks and Tania Franco described the materials now available for scholars and the public, including a wealth of correspondence and other documents at Avery, with Wright’s models and other three-dimensional materials at MoMA. The labors of untangling and organizing Tafel’s writings and records were formidable, as reflected in Franco’s meta-archiving blog. What emerges is a portrait of an energetic, engaged, complex urban citizen, the product of a progressive upbringing in his youth and a prolific contributor to the architectural literature in his maturity. With Avery serving as a kind of posthumous virtual Taliesin, master and apprentice are now back together. On some level, one would like to imagine that Mr. Wright has made his peace with New York at last.

Bill Millard is a freelance writer and editor whose work has appeared in Oculus, IconThe Architect’s Newspaper, and other publications.

Event: Practice Post-50: Edgar Tafel in New York
Location: Center for Architecture, 01.23. 14
Speakers: Janet Parks, Curator of Drawings and Archives, Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library, Columbia University; Tania Franco, Project Archivist, Edgar Tafel Archive; Kimbro Frutiger, Architect, Author, Edgar Tafel’s Religious Work: Design, Traditions, Ethics; Caroline Rob Zaleski, Author, Edgar Tafel and SUNY Geneseo: Lessons from Frank Lloyd Wright; Robert Silman, President Emeritus, Robert Silman Associates (moderator); Carol Ann Fabian, Director, Avery Library (introduction); Rick Bell, FAIA, AIANY Executive Director
Organizers: Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library, Columbia University and AIANY Historic Buildings Committee

Comments are closed.

Alex Alaimo, AIA, AIA National Associates Committee, interviews AIANY and Center for Architecture Executive Director Benjamin Prosky.
YOUNG ARCHITECTS WANTED! From the Executive Director
Special Citation: ARE Instructors
Annual Meeting 2016 Uncategorized
Lobbying Law: Amnesty Period Ends Soon! AIA News You Can Use
Closing Keynote: Understanding Neighborhood Change: Voices of a Gentrifying New York by
Eleven Years of Progress: FitCity 2016 Policy Pulse
Speakers of Large Movements of Refugees and Migrants: Critical Challenges for Sustainable Urbanization
Large Movements of Refugees and Migrants: Critical Challenges for Sustainable Urbanization From the Desk of the President
15th Architecture Exhibition, La Biennale di Venezia
More than a Building: The 15th Venice Architecture Biennale Reports from the Field
Partners in Design: Alfred Barr and Philipp Johnson
Oculus Book Review: Partners in Design: Alfred Barr and Philip Johnson Book Reviews
A Genealogy of Modern Architecture by Kenneth Frampton.
Oculus Quick Take: A Genealogy of Modern Architecture Podcast
Speakers of “The Education of the Architect: Incorporating Social Science."
The Ways and Whys of Incorporating Social Science Methodologies into Architecture Curricula At the Center for Architecture
Students at the Center for Architecture's first after-school program.
Exploring Architecture: After School at the Center Learning by Design
1 - Photo Finish
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
“EXTRA-ORDINARY: New Practices in Chilean Architecture,” through 09.03.16
On View On View
09.16.16: Call for Entries: AIANY COTE Awards 2016
New Deadlines New Deadlines
06.07.16: Annabelle Selldorf, FAIA, Principal of Selldorf Architects and 2016 AIANY Medal of Honor recipient, was joined at the Center for Architecture by Vishaan Chakrabarti, Founder of Partnership for Architecture & Urbanism, to discuss the role of architects today.
Sighted Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
Join us at the AIANY Annual Meeting! Editor's Note
NYC Lobbying Law: What You Need to Know Policy Pulse
From the portfolio of Sergey Pigach, 2016 Allwork Scholarship recipient.
2016 Center for Architecture Design Scholarship and Eleanor Allwork Scholarship Recipients Center News
A Burglar's Guide to the City by Geoff Manaugh.
Oculus Book Review: A Burglar’s Guide to the City by Geoff Manaugh Book Reviews
Speakers and organizers of "Connecting Research and Age-Friendly Design," organized by the AIANY Social Science and Architecture Committee and the AIANY Design for Aging Committee.
Connecting Research and Age-Friendly Design At the Center for Architecture
Students from the IS 392 Architecture Club pose with their models for redesigning the school’s Journalism Lab and key project leaders. (l-r) Howard Stern, Design Educator, Center for Architecture; IS 392 Alise Braick, STEM Teacher, and Loren Cooper, Assistant Principal;  Penda Aiken, Chair, Teach to Excel Foundation; and IS 392 Principal Ingrid Joseph.
Students Propose New Designs for Their School’s Journalism Lab Learning by Design
Walter A. Hunt, Jr., FAIA
Walter A. Hunt, Jr., FAIA (1941 – 2016) In Memoriam
Fred Shen at the Shen Milsom & Wilke’s 30th anniversary celebration on 05.11.16.
In Memoriam: Fred Shen (1942 – 2016) In Memoriam
1 - The Regeneration of Red Hook
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
09.16.16: Call for Entries: AIANY COTE Awards 2016
New Deadlines New Deadlines
"New Practices New York 2016, "through 07.23.16
On View On View
06.06.16: Margery Perlmutter, Esq., RA, Chair of the New York City Board of Standards and Appeals, discussed how the BSA operates and how it can help enhance the viability and design of development projects in NYC.
Sighted Sighted
Courtesy Faena Hotel; Photographer NickKoenig
Classifieds Classifieds
Congratulations to the 149 AIA members (and 18 AIANY members) inducted to the AIA College of Fellows.
Dispatch from the 2016 AIA National Convention: Phil-AIA-delphia From the Executive Director
FitCity 2016
Policy Pulse: FitCity 2016 Policy Pulse
Congratulations to the Robert A.M. Stern Architects (RAMA) team, winners of Guess-A-Sketch 2016!
Guess-A-Sketch Raises over $100K for NYC Schoolchildren At the Center for Architecture
Convention Special: Hudson Yards – New York’s First Post-Digital Neighborhood Reports from the Field
Speakers of " Exploring the Past, Defining the Future: The History of Social Science and Architecture."
Social Science Challenging and Reinforcing Spatial Design: From Çatalhöyük to Networked Innovation Communities At the Center for Architecture
Second- and third-grade students at PS 132 in Washington Heights showcased the bridges they designed in a 10-week Learning By Design:NY program .
Learning By Design:NY Wrap-up Learning by Design
Aldo Giurgola (1920 – 2016)
In Memoriam: Two Tributes to Aldo Giurgola (1920 – 2016) In Memoriam
1 - Basic Black
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
New Deadlines New Deadlines
"New Practices New York 2016," through 07.23.16
On View About Town
05.12.16: The winners of the 2016 AIANY New Practices New York competition discussed their work at the opening of the New Practices New York 2016 exhibition. (l-r) Phu Hoang, AIA, and Rachely Rotem, MODU; Troy Schaum and Rosalyne Shieh, AIA, SCHAUM/SHIEH; Bryan Young, AIA, Young Projects; Benjamin Cadena, AIA, Studio Cadena; Seung Teak Lee, stpmj; Ines Guzman and Gregory Melitonov, Assoc. AIA, Taller KEN; and James Slade, FAIA, IIDA, LEED AP, Slade Architecture.
Sighted Sighted
Innovative Wellness Design Seminar and Reception
Classifieds Classifieds
Suzanne Mecs, Hon. AIANYS, Managing Director, AIANY; Eric Goshow, AIA, LEED AP, Director for Legislative Affairs, AIANY; Carol Loewenson, FAIA, 2016 President, AIANY; Lance Jay Brown, FAIA, Co-chair, AIANY Design for Risk and Reconstruction Committee; Sherida Paulsen, FAIA, Principal, PKSB Architects; David Piscuskas, FAIA, LEED AP, President-Elect, AIANY; Venesa Alicea, AIA, LEED AP BD+C, Alternate Director for Professional Development, AIANY; Benjamin Prosky, Executive Director, AIANY; and Emma Pattiz, Policy Coordinator, AIANY
Advocating for Architects in Albany From the Executive Director
AIA Convention, Philadelphia 05.19-21.16
AIA Convention 2016 Editor's Note
NYC Department of Transportation Street Design Manual
Your Input Requested for the Future of NYC Streets Policy Pulse
Despina Stratigakos discusses her latest book, Where Are the Women Architects?
Oculus Book Review: Where are the Women Architects? by Despina Stratigakos Book Reviews
Organizers and speakers of "Heat Waves: Preparing for and Managing the Effects of Extreme Heat on Health, Populations, Emergency Housing, and Hospitals."
No Disasters According to Plan, but the Hot Ones are Inevitable At the Center for Architecture
Christopher Benninger, Principal, CCBA Architects
Christopher Benninger: Designing India’s Universities At the Center for Architecture
1 - LGBT Sacred Space Opens for Worship and Life-cycle Events
In the News In The News