Lorenzo Vascotto discussing general contractors v. project managers during "Leading Architecture in a Changing World: Digital Strategies for Architects and Our Clients"
Lorenzo Vascotto discussing general contractors v. project managers during "Leading Architecture in a Changing World: Digital Strategies for Architects and Our Clients"

Project Management New York Style: It is about how, not what, you buy

At the Center for Architecture by • 05/01

The relationship between architect and project manager can be fraught with complexity; many anecdotes suggest that projects run smoothly when both are in place, while almost everyone also has a war-story or two about the time that the two were at odds and disaster ensued. While project managers may argue that costs increase due to “design creep,” architects are fending off a wide variety of other client service providers. In other words, one might argue that costs are rising instead from “consultant creep.”

Lorenzo Vascotto, a founding partner currently serving as managing director at VVA Project Managers & Consultants, was game to take on this topic and many others during the Professional Practice Committee’s fourth program of the “Leading Architecture in a Changing World” series, which culminates on 06.17.13 with “Entrepreneurship in Architecture and Beyond.”

Vascotto presented an honest look at the differences between general contractor (GC) and construction management (GM), specifically focusing on the impacts of their decisions on, among others, design quality, cost to deliver, reliability of cost, and use of change orders.

VVA, is a leading independent project management firm founded in New York City over 19 years ago, is best known for offering a full range of advisory and technical project management services in the real estate and construction arenas. Vascotto brings a technical and financial approach to his work that was honed during the 13 years before founding VVA. He served as an engineer at Syska & Hennessy, which laid the technical and mechanical foundation for his career. He further expanded his knowledge of real estate, facilities management, and finance, during his seven year tenure at Goldman Sachs.

The first portion of Vascotto’s presentation focused on the practical differences between general contractor and construction management for project delivery. From his experience, he’s found that design delivery with a GC may be 10-15% cheaper due to a number of drivers including competition, business experience, risk absorption, and actual services delivered. There was then some conversation about the value of those services, and the kinds of projects and clients that benefit from each.

The opinions of both Vascotto and the audience revealed that our industry still seems to have a significant amount of cost volatility. Relaying recent experience in comparing construction bids, Vascotto saw budgets/fees/proposals with 15-20% price differentiation. He explained that, unlike in Europe, where quantity surveying is a licensed profession, cost estimators are less prominent in the United States marketplace and their level of expertise is more varied; this is one of many roles that project managers are supporting.

One of Vascotto’s key points: it is all about “how you buy, not just what you buy.” He emphasized that asking the right questions during the bid and negotiation process is essential to mitigating risk and making sure that expectations are met later on. He generally aims to require that the final selected delivery team commits to the design intent, not the letter of the drawing. At the end of a bid sequence, he often goes back and negotiates a Guaranteed Maximum Price. He advocates clear and open communications to reduce “change order mania.”

Vascotto finally described ways to achieve price control throughout the process, including pre-purchase pricing of carpet, walls, furniture, lighting, doors and hardware, and other items, locking in the cheaper – and often better – option.

Audience member Peter Matthews of Matthews Moya Architects offered a keen observation and potential solution, explaining that “the perception of the creative architect is a double-edged sword, that as design costs increase, we often appear to be part of the problem, contributing to the cost, rather than helping to control it.”  He said that one way his practice has mitigated that perception and limited cost increases, while preserving design quality, is by locking in prices on premium items early on, sometimes through purchase, other times just by getting a bid and price commitment.

For better or worse, there also seems to be power in being big. Vascotto’s presentation emphasized the role of social, political, and industry prominence as way to access better results in the construction and design-delivery worlds, particularly in New York City. He mentioned revenue volume and potential for repeat business as one of the key reasons contractors deliver services on time, as well as leverage in negotiations.

At event’s end, the conversation shifted to a debate on several topics including those that cut to the quick of architectural fees, from value engineering to a constant barrage of new players, and challenges around who is closest to the client – when and for what purpose. Further conversations will surely be required.

Melissa Marsh is a workplace strategy and change management consultant with an architectural education. She recently founded her own company, Plastarc. She is new contributor to e-Oculus, and can be reached at melissa@plastarc.com.

Event: Leading Architecture in a Changing World: Digital Strategies for Architects and Our Clients
Location: Center for Architecture, 03.22.13
Speaker: Lorenzo Vascotto, Founding Partner and Managing Director, VVA Project Managers & Consultants
Organizers: AIANY Chapter Professional Practice Committee and AIANY staff

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

"New Practices New York 2014" is on view at the Center for Architecture through 01.17.15
Happy New Year! Editor's Note
Tomas Rossant, AIA, and Joseph Tortorella hold the keys to the Center for Architecture.
From the Desk of the President From the Desk of the President
Via Verde
Examining the Gauntlet In Response
Constadino (Gus) Sirakis, PE, Gina L. Bocra, AIA, LEED AP BD+C/ID+C, and Emily Hoffman, PE, CEM, LEED AP, CPMP, from the NYC Department of Buildings presented on the updated energy code to a packed house on 1.12.15.
Environmentalism at the Forefront Policy Pulse
12.08.14: A panel of experts discussed issues in the Far West Side following a presentation of New York’s New Edge: Contemporary Art, the Highline, and Urban Megaprojects on the Far West Side at the December 2014 Oculus Book Talk.
Oculus Book Review: “New York’s New Edge: Contemporary Art, the High Line, and Urban Megaprojects on the Far West Side” At the Center for Architecture
"New York’s New Edge: Contemporary Art, the High Line, and Urban Megaprojects on the Far West Side"
Oculus Quick Take: “New York’s New Edge: Contemporary Art, the High Line, and Urban Megaprojects on the Far West Side” Podcast
Villa E.1027 by Eileen Gray is one of the houses Greben will visit on her trip.
Announcing the Winners of the 2014 Stewardson Keefe LeBrun Travel Grant Center News
1 - Local or Global? FIGMENT Chooses Both!
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
02.06.15: Call for Entries: AIANY Design Awards 2015
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“Metropolitan Waterfront Alliance's Waterfront Edge Design Guidelines (WEDG)” opening 01.22.15
On View About Town
01.12.15: AIANY Executive Director Rick Bell, FAIA, invited the audience to pick up their own copies of Urban Alchemy: Restoring Joy in America’s Sorted-Out Cities, at the Oculus Book Talk featuring author Dr. Mindy Thompson Fullilove, and William Morrish of Parsons The New School for Design.
Sighted Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
Illustration by Inbal Newman
Happy Holidays! Editor's Note
Lance Jay Brown, FAIA and Rick Bell, FAIA with 2015 AIA National President Elizabeth Chu Richter, FAIA at the inaugural in Washington, DC on 12/12/14.
Message from the President From the Desk of the President
AIANY 2014 President Lance Jay Brown, FAIA (right), passes the gavel to AIANY 2015 President Tomas Rossant, AIA.
AIANY 2015 Board Inaugural At the Center for Architecture
On 12.06.14 and 12.07.14 the AIANY Design for Risk and Reconstruction Committee (DfRR) hosted HURRIPLAN Resilient Building Design for Coastal Communities, a training course on integrating resilient community planning and building design strategies with civic and commercial projects located in hurricane-prone areas, at City College.
Lobbying for Libraries Policy Pulse
Speakers and organizers of Inclusionary/Integrated Housing Part 1 of 2: Community Development
Planning with the Community in East New York At the Center for Architecture
AIANY 2014 President Lance Jay Brown, FAIA. On the screen: Program bubble diagram of a two-bed Ebola Biocontainment Unit designed by Atelier New York Architecture, typical of small BCUs being planned at state-designated institutions in anticipation of possible local pandemics.
Designing to Outsmart Ebola: Time to Think about the Unthinkable At the Center for Architecture
Speakers of "Community Schools: Process, Program, and Promise." (l-r) Mark Thaler, AIA, Gensler; Kimberly Murphya, AIA, Edelman Sultan Knox Wood / Architects; Jack Doyle, New Settlement Apartments; Jeffrey Dugan, AIA, Dattner; and Vincent Lee, Rogers Partners Architects+Urban Designers.
Two Cools for School At the Center for Architecture
Paradise Planned: The Garden Suburb and the Modern City
Oculus Quick Take: Paradise Planned Podcast
Learning By Design:NY residency at PS 102.
Looking Back, Looking Forward At the Center for Architecture Foundation
1 - The Cooper Hewitt Reopens after Three Years of Work by 13 Design Firms
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
02.06.15: Call for Entries: AIANY Design Awards 2015
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“New Practices New York 2014” through 01.17.15
On View: At the Center for Architecture At the Center for Architecture
AIANY 2015 President Tomas Rossant, AIA, and Center for Architecture 2015 President Joseph Tortorella received the keys to the Center for Architecture during the Center for Architecture Foundation / AIA New York Chapter joint board meeting. Also shown: Catherine Teegarden; Carol Loewenson, FAIA; and Lance Jay Brown, FAIA.
Sighted Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
AIANY 2015 President Tomas Rossant, AIA, and AIANY 2014 President Lance Jay Brown, FAIA (center).
Editor’s Note Editor's Note
Paul Katz, FAIA
In Memoriam: Paul Katz In Memoriam
On 11.20.14, the NYC Department of City Planning organized a panel discussion on retrofitting urban buildings for flood risk.
Equitable Efficiency Policy Pulse
Alan Mallach, senior fellow of the National Housing Institute, senior fellow at the Center for Community Progress, and senior fellow at the Brookings Institution.
Samuel Ratensky Memorial Lecture Transcript At the Center for Architecture
13 area architecture school deans discussed leadership at the 2014 Deans' Roundtable.
2014 Deans’ Roundtable At the Center for Architecture
David Fishman, co-author of Paradise Planned, presented on the evolution of suburbs at the November 2014 Oculus Book Talk.
Oculus Book Review: Paradise Planned: The Garden Suburb and the Modern City, by Robert A.M. Stern, David Fishman, and Jacob Tilove At the Center for Architecture
Rick Bell, FAIA, AIANY; Elin Bergithe Rognlie, Consulate General of Norway; Ingrid Moe, Consulate General of Norway; Kati Laakso, Consulate General of Finland in New York; Emmi Keskisarja, Architect; Miia-Liina Tommila, Architect; Caitlin Mehner, Performer; and David Gelles, Performer
Infinite Diversities At the Center for Architecture
Stanis Smith, FRAIC, AIA, LEED AP, Executive Vice President for Buildings, Sector Leader, Airports, Stantec
Zip-a-ding Through the Airport: Place-Oriented Playlands At the Center for Architecture
Rick Bell, FAIA, AIANY; Gabriel Smith, AIA, Thomas Phifer and Partners; Lee H. Skolnick, FAIA, Lee H. Skolnick Architecture + Design Partnership; Scott Briggs, AIA, AIANY Cultural Facilities Committee; Audrey Matlock, FAIA, Audrey Matlock Architect; and Katie Gerfen, Architect magazine
American Architects Working in Post-Soviet Culture Sectors At the Center for Architecture
Hana Kassem, AIA, LEED AP, Kohn Pedersen Fox Associates; Lance Jay Brown, FAIA, AIANY; Alejandro Zaera-Polo, AZPML; Florian Idenburg, Intl. Assoc. AIA, SO-IL; Dan Gallagher, NADAAA; Nader Tehrani, NADAAA; and Hashim Sarkis, MIT School of Architecture and Planning
Melting Pot At the Center for Architecture
The Center for Architecture Foundation (CFAF) hosted the annual Architecture and Design College Fair on 11.21.14
CFAF Hosts Architecture and Design College Fair At the Center for Architecture Foundation
1 - Fantasy Island
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
02.06.15: Call for Entries: AIANY Design Awards 2015
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“Saul Steinberg Drawings | Architecture Public Space” through 01.03.15
On View: At the Center for Architecture + About Town About Town
11.13.14: At the “Geometry and Structure in Architecture” event, organized by the Center for Architecture and the Museum of the City of New York, speakers discussed the interactions between mathematics and geometry in architecture. (l-r) SawTeen See, Managing Partner, and Leslie E. Robertson, Founder, Leslie E. Robertson Associates; William F. Baker, Structural Engineering Partner, Skidmore, Owings & Merrill; Erleen Hatfield, AIA, LEED AP, PE, Principal, Buro Happold; and Susan Henshaw Jones, Ronay Menschel Director, Museum of the City of New York.
Sighted Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
11.15.14: "Arch Schools 2014" and Deans' Roundtable
Editor’s Note Editor's Note
AIA Europe founder Alan Schwartzman, FAIA, shown here with AIA National Vice President Susan Chin, FAIA, received a prolonged standing ovation while receiving two AIA Europe awards.
Musings on AIA in Europe Rhetorically Speaking
Roland Lewis, Roland Lewis, President & CEO, Metropolitan Waterfront Alliance, introduces the South Street Seaport Public Forum on 10.10.14.
Planning the ‘Port: A Public Conversation on Development at the South Street Seaport Policy Pulse
Alexander Garvin, president and CEO of Alex Garvin & Associates and professor at Yale School of Architecture presented on the creation of a light rail line to connect Queens to Brooklyn.
Millenials Bring Back the Trolley? At the Center for Architecture
William Menking, Architect’s Newspaper; Sara Reisman, Percent for Art Program, NYC Department of Cultural Affairs; Aleksey Lukyanov-Cherny, Situ Studio; Susan Chin, FAIA, Design Trust for Public Space; James Carpenter, James Carpenter Design Associates; Sandra Bloodworth, Arts and Urban Design, MTA; and Andrew Whalley, Grimshaw.
Publicly Available At the Center for Architecture