AIANY 2014 President Lance Jay Brown, FAIA
AIANY 2014 President Lance Jay Brown, FAIA

Ethics and the Road to Convention: Durban and Chicago

From the Desk of the President by • 04/30

As we prepare for the next meeting of the International Union of Architects (UIA) in Durban, South Africa, this August, we are confronted with a proposal that demands we take an immediate position. Reporter Harriet Sherwood wrote about the proposal on 03.20.14 in London’s The Guardian. Since the matter surfaced, there have been endless articles, e-mails, and calls. While some think it may all blow over, we cannot allow it to be floated without immediate objection.

The Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA) plans to bring a proposal to the floor of the upcoming 2014 bi-annual meeting of the UIA. The RIBA has demanded the suspension of the Israeli Association of United Architects (IAUA) from the UIA, saying it is complicit in the construction of illegal settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, and other violations of international law. While former RIBA President Angela Brady told a meeting of its council how important the proposal was, other council members pointed to human rights violations in other parts of the world, such as North Korea, which is a member of the UIA, asking why they should not be held to similar standards. Notable architects and members of AIANY have spoken out or written against the RIBA proposal, including Richard Meier, FAIA, and Daniel Libeskind, AIA.

AIANY Executive Director Rick Bell, FAIA, and I drafted a letter denouncing the RIBA proposal. The grounds upon which our draft was based centered on inclusion and dialogue, as opposed to exclusion and highly prejudicial, selective condemnation. The letter was put before the AIANY Board at its last meeting on 04.22.14. While certain details and some personalization were criticized, the general sense of the letter was approved. All thought it inappropriate for the RIBA to exclude an entire country’s architects – both Israeli and Palestinian – because the RIBA takes issue with the politics of that country. As the mission statement of the UIA is “to unite the architects of the world without any form of discrimination,” it should be obvious that excluding one country’s architects defeats the purpose.

A final draft of the letter was circulated to the Board and approved for forwarding to the RIBA. In addition, I will be writing a personal letter to the president of the Royal Institute of British Architects categorically objecting to the RIBA proposal. If you would like to write a letter as well, please address to: Royal Institute of British Architects, 66 Portland Place, London, W1B 1AD, United Kingdom.

On another front, AIANY’s president, executive director, Academy of Architecture for Justice (AAJ), Executive, and Policy Committees, and the entire AIANY Board wrestled with the ethical issues related to the architect’s role in the design of facilities for incarceration. This was in response to the Architects/Designers/Planners for Social Responsibility (ADPSR) request for an amendment to the AIA Code of Ethics prohibiting the design of spaces used for solitary confinement and capital punishment. The ADPSR wants this change to be brought to the floor at the AIA 2014 Convention in Chicago. Serious business to be taken seriously. Dialogue and discussion went on for a year before an opinion was rendered.

The AAJ commentary, with which the Board agreed, included: “Solitary confinement is a practice; it is not a specific type of space to be designed. To insert a specific prohibition in the Code of Ethics, as opposed to providing practitioners with evidence-based guidelines, is a misuse of the Code. The question of capital punishment, however abhorrent it may be to those among us, fits along a continuum of controversial practices, like abortion and assisted suicide, for which there is a lack of consensus within our society. The cultural discussion about such issues is far from settled, with no clear consensus within sight. For the AIA to take an ethical stance, forbidding its members to design facilities that are otherwise legal, and in this case, facilities for governmental activities, risks alienating membership in support of an advocacy position. These issues of design relative to solitary confinement and capital punishment are advocacy issues, not ethical ones.”

The statement concluded: “The AIA, through the AAJ, should support the development of a document that defines Best Practices for Corrections Planning and Design in order to promote evidence-based approaches to correctional design and operations. The AAJ is the AIA’s Knowledge Community with expert members capable of such an initiative. Its recent white paper, ‘Sustainable Justice: Green Guide to Justice,’ is an example of results from such an initiative. It promotes systems, scale, and sustainable approaches to correctional facilities that are Smaller, Kinder and Greener, with greater opportunities for successful outcomes for staff, inmates, and communities. A similar approach involving best practices for corrections planning and design is a more effective way of inducing change and addressing advocacy rather than banning AIA members from designing specific space types. AAJ NY plans to bring a proposal to AAJ National at the 2014 AIA convention for a sub-committee to develop Best Practice Guidelines: Design for Humane, Effective Segregation.”

It was proposed and agreed that the AIA New York Chapter should promote dialogues that address the serious issues of ethics and architecture, and that plans for such discussions should be developed for the near future.

Comments are closed.

Benjamin Prosky, Assoc. AIA, Executive Director, AIANY and Center for Architecture
Archtober Itinerary Word of Mouth
STUDIOS Architecture's winning cake: Zaha Hadid's Heydar Aliyev Center in Azerbaijan.
High-Calorie High Rises: The Great Architectural Bake-Off Reports from the Field
The AIANYS board enjoys an architect-led tour of the Algonquin Building, originally designed by S. Gifford Slocum, during the 2016 AIA New York State Saratoga Design Conference.
In Architecture, Collaboration is Key Reports from the Field
Bruce Fowle, FAIA, LEED AP, accepts the 2016 AIANYS President's Award.
AIA New York State President’s Award: Green is Beautiful Word of Mouth
AIA Presidential Profiles.
AIA Presidential Candidate Profiles Policy Pulse
1 - A New Museum Has Got Lady Liberty’s Back
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
New Deadlines New Deadlines
"Reading Room: A Catalog of New York City's Branch Libraries," through 01.07.16.
On View On View
10.01.16: Archtober 2016 kicked off its Building of the Day series with a guided tour of Samsung 837, the brand’s digital playground in the Meatpacking District, designed by Gensler (interior), and Morris Adjmi Architects (exterior).
Sighted: Archtober Edition Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
Archtober 2016 is coming!
Archtober Fast Approaches Editor's Note
Architects, Pick Your Leaders! AIA News You Can Use
David Rockwell, FAIA
Archtober Itinerary: David Rockwell, FAIA Word of Mouth
"Authenticity and Innovation" curator Donald Albrecht.
5 Questions with Donald Albrecht On View
Architects Advocate: Action on Climate Change
Architects Advocate for Climate Change Action Policy Pulse
Recoded City: Co-creating Urban Futures by Thomas Ermacora and Lucy Bullivant
Oculus Book Review: Recoded City: Co-creating Urban Futures Book Reviews
2016 New York Architects’ Regatta Challenge
2016 New York Architects’ Regatta Challenge: More Wind, Please Reports from the Field
1 - Not Super-Tall, but Still Living the High Life
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
New Deadlines New Deadlines
"Authenticity and Innovation," opening 09.30.16
On View On View
Classifieds Classifieds
Renovations at the Center From the Executive Director
Archtober kicked off at Samsung 837, Building of the Day #1.
Archtober’s Cool Kick-Off Reports from the Field
Second Annual AIA I Look Up Film Challenge
People’s Choice: Vote for the AIA I Look Up Film Challenge AIA News You Can Use
New York City’s Energy and Water Use 2013 Report.
New Energy Report Highlights Architects’ Role Policy Pulse
Partners in Design: Alfred H. Barr Jr. and Philip Johnson
Partners in Design: Alfred H. Barr Jr. and Philip Johnson In Memoriam
John Belle, FAIA (1932-2016)
In Memoriam: John Belle, FAIA (1932-2016) In Memoriam
1 - Design for Final Piece of WTC Master Plan Revealed
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
09.23.16: Call for Entries: AIANY COTE Awards 2016
New Deadlines New Deadlines
Reading Room: A Catalog of New York City's Branch Libraries
On View On View
09.12.16: At the September Oculus Book Talk, Lucy Bullivant, Ph.D., Hon. FRIBA, Founder and Creative Director of, discussed her latest book, Recoded City: Co-creating Urban Futures, co-authored with Thomas Ermarcora. Following her talk, she was joined in a panel, moderated by William Menking, Editor-in-Chief, The Architect’s Newspaper, with Adam Lubinsky, PhD, Managing Principal, WXY architecture + urban design, and Alex Alaimo, Assoc. AIA, Founder, ORLI.
Sighted Sighted
Classifieds Classifieds
Tweet-for-Treat! We'll be at Samsung 837 on 98.29.16 giving away free ice cream!
Archtober Tweet-for-Treat! Editor's Note
Borinquen Court affordable and senior housing center in The Bronx, by Red Top Architects.
Aging in Place Policy Pulse
A rendering of J. MAYER H. und Partner, Architekten's latest project, XXX TIMES SQUARE WITH LOVE.
Jürgen Mayer H. Speaks on Reactivating Public Space in Times Square and Beyond At the Center for Architecture
FIGMENT: What Is This? Why Is Nothing for Sale? Why Is Everyone Smiling? by David Koren.
Oculus Book Review: FIGMENT: What Is This? Why Is Nothing for Sale? Why Is Everyone Smiling? Book Reviews
Dark Space: Architecture, Representation, Black Identity by Mario Gooden, AIA.
Oculus Podcast: Dark Space: Architecture, Representation, Black Identity Podcast
1 - Grafting an Expansion on a Landmark
In the News In The News
Names in the News Names in the News
The AIANY COTE Awards recognize results-oriented achievements in the urban context. Deadline 09.16.15
New Deadlines New Deadlines
“EXTRA-ORDINARY: New Practices in Chilean Architecture,” through 09.03.16.
On View On View
Classifieds Classifieds
Lower Manhattan Then map.
Mapping Lower Manhattan Center News
“Tentolana” by Tom Krizmanic
Imagining Olana’s Summer House Reports from the Field
AIA New York State’s 2016 Design Conference
Come, Collaborate: AIANYS 2016 Design Conference AIA News You Can Use
DOB NOW Continues Expansion Policy Pulse
Malik Knight, a second-year student at Philadelphia University, volunteered to assist students in developing their projects over the two week studio.
When Does the Education of an Architect Begin? Learning by Design